Friday, October 29, 2010

Deceptively Delicious Heath Cake

Probably the BEST cake ever...

As a little girl growing up in rural Indiana, I lived for the days when a family function would prompt someone to make a Heath bar cake and give me a piece of the yummy goodness.  :-)  This cake didn't come around very often, but when it did, I was in heaven.  I recently discovered the recipe in an old church cookbook.  You know you have a gem of a cookbook when it's compiled by a group of ladies from a country church.  I had always assumed the recipe to be complicated, but it is so easy!  If you're on the search for an incredibly moist, sweet cake with a little bit of a toffee kick, try the recipe below.  

Heath Cake Recipe:

1 box German chocolate cake mix** 
     -vegetable oil, water, 3 eggs
1 container of Cool Whip
1 jar caramel ice cream topping
3 Heath candy bars
**I prefer Pillsbury cake mix because it has a pudding mix in the batter that makes the cake even more moist.

  1. Mix and bake cake as directed on the box for a 13x9" cake pan.
  2. While the cake is still hot and fresh out of the oven, use the blunt end of a wooden spoon (or similar utensil) to poke holes in the cake.  Each hole should be about an inch apart (evenly placed).  Be careful not to poke the holes too deeply into the cake.
  3. Pour the entire jar of caramel ice cream topping over the cake.  Try to pour most of the topping into the holes.  Again, this needs to be done while the cake is still hot.
  4. Put the cake directly into the refrigerator and let chill for 4-6 hours.
  5. While the cake is cooling, chop the Heath bars into tiny pieces.
  6. Once the cake is COLD, cover it in Cool Whip.
  7. Sprinkle candy pieces all over the cake.
  8. Cover the cake and refrigerate until ready to serve!


  1. Sounds yummy. I am a new follower from blog hop. stop by any time.

  2. Hi! Thanks for participating in the All Hallows Eve Blog Hop! Im your newest follower! Have a safe and Happy Halloween!


  3. Hi! I am a new follower from Friday's blog hops. I am looking forward to reading more of your blog. Blessings...
    Saved By Love Creations

  4. Happy Hauntings!! Oh wow...this looks delicious! Thanks for following from All Hallows Eve....returning the "follow" luv! :)

    Mother of Pearl It Is

  5. Ok first thing is first! I won't hold it against your beautiful happy baby that she is wearing an IU onsie. I know it isn't her fault. Do you need me to send her a PURDUE one?? haha Boilermaker here!
    Second, babies are exhausting. I never stops. My babies are 16, 16 and 11. I'm still exhausted and my house isn't clean! My girls are happy and healthy and their dad and I are going strong after 17 years of marriage. Im here to tell you to Hug and Kiss and be there for them first, everything else will fall into place.
    Finally----Stopping over to BOOOoooooboboooboooooboooo on your page from the Creepy Crawl! I am stalking you I mean following your blog!

    Stop over bc someone got murdered on my BLOG!